Stars (in credits order)
Craig Melvin
Self - Host
Kate Snow
Keith Morrison
Self - Correspondent
Andrea Canning
Josh Mankiewicz
Dennis Murphy
Natalie Morales
Lester Holt
Hoda Kotb
Chris Jansing
Edie Magnus
Troy Roberts
Rob Stafford
Mike Taibbi
Stephanie Gosk
Ida Lopez
Self
Jane Lant
Cindy Karlsen
John McAfee
Amanda Lindhout
Vashti Seacat
John Hamilton
Jimmy Keene
Sandra Jessee
Jodi Arias
Karl H. Karlsen
Erika Friman
Justine Winter
Kenneth Williams
Travis Alexander
Raymond Highers
Charles Capone
Buck Blodgett
James Biela
Don Winner
Thomas Highers
Pedro Bravo
Noel Stevens
Aasha Davis
Jesse Pforzheimer
Fabian Ayala
Self - Son of Roberto Ayala
Jonah Shacknai
Self - Max’s father
Derek Mois
Self - Detective
Judy Melinek
Self - Forensic Pathologist
Mary Zahau-Loehner
Self - Rebecca’s sister
Adam Shacknai
Self - Jonah’s brother
Dina Shacknai
Self - Max’s mother
Tara Schneider
Self - Intelligence Analyst
Keith Greer
Self - Attorney for the Zahau Family
Carl Marlinga
Self - Defense Attorney, Macomb County
Madette Bui
Self - Juror
Bill Cataldo
Self - Prosecutor, Macomb County
Kay Daniels
Steve Fox
Jimmy Hall
Self - Detective, Clinton Township Police Dept.
Lenny Hrecho
Steve Kaplan
Kris Kehoe
Self - Emergency room nurse
Craig Keith
Self - Lead Detective, Clinton Township Police Dept.
Joe Kowynia
Self - Barbara George's brother
Jeff Lively
Self - Electrical Supply Owner
Mike Renaud
Self - Customer of Barbara George
Mary Shamo
Self - Joe Kowynia's girlfriend
Eric Smith
Self - Chief Prosecutor, Macomb County
Donald Steckman
Self - Detective Sergeant, Clinton Township Police Dept.
Lenora Ward
Tom Ward
Brad Westover
Self - Pastor
Amber Frey
Self - Who helped uncover the truth
David Jenkins
Self - Detective, Reno P.D.
James Zywicki
Self - Investigator
