Stars (in credits order)
Zak Bagans
Self - Host
Aaron Goodwin
Self
Keith L. Hall
Theodore
Billy Tolley
Jay Wasley
Nancy Knapp
Self - Zak's Mom
Ashley Richardson
Dan McIntyre
Self - Former Owner, Ed Gein Cauldron
Eric Murphy
Self - Antique Dealer
Cindy Lee
Self - Owner, Bela Lugosi's Mirror
Ron Nelson
Self - Owner of The Splendour Yacht
Jayne Harris
Self - Owner of Peggy the Doll
Dennis Davern
Self - Former Captain of Splendour
Joe Tasso
Self - Bonnie Springs Ranch
Carneth Brown
Self - Grand Marsh, WI
Lana Wood
Self - Sister of Natalie Wood
Courtney Dyar
Irene Lee
Self - Daughter
Derek Wagner
Katrin Reedik
Self - Victim of Peggy the Doll
Jason Haxton
Self - Owner, Dibbuk Box
Trevor Jones
Self - Director of Historical Resources, Kentucky Historical Society
Jackie
Kevin Mannis
Self - Former Owner, Dibbuk Box
Geoffrey Fieger
Self - Kevorkian's Former Attorney
Beverly Kienzle
Self - Retired Professor, Harvard Divinity School
Patti Negri
Self - Professional Psychic
Geoff Schumacher
Self - Director of Content, Mob Museum
Tina Booth
Self - Owner, Crying Boy Painting
Annie St. John
Self - Lives in Kevorkian's Old Home
Nick Kloster
Self - Owner, Charles Manson's TV
Brett K. Maly
Self - Art Expert
Yitz Wyne
Self - Young Israel Aish Synagogue
Teresa Torres
Self - Educator, Mob Museum
Ashley J. Krick
Self - Nick's Friend
Jason Freeman
Self - Charles Manson's Grandson
Cori Convertito
Self - Caretaker, Robert the Doll
Maggie Booth
Self - Tina's Daughter
Sj Sayegh
Self - Elite Audio & Customs
David Steinke
Self - Antique Collector
Bonnie Randolph
Self - Key West, Florida
McLovin
Mary Skinner
Self - Tennessee State Museum
Doug Loman
Self - Pastor
Sara Harvey
Self - Eyewitness
Jamie Pistel
Self - Descendent of John Murrell
Bud Steed
David Ney
Ignacyo Matynia
Detective (uncredited)
Lia Russo
Annie (uncredited)
Ty Vaughn
Robb Hudspeth
Nick (uncredited)
Michael Power
Ed Gein (uncredited)
Charlie Meany
Robert Wagner (uncredited)
Mark C. Fullhardt
Gangster (uncredited)
Michael Lepre
Patient (uncredited)
Robert Kabakoff
Geoffrey Fieger (uncredited)
Darrell Chumley
Charles Manson (uncredited)
Anita Rosner
Don Capone
Mark Twain (uncredited)
Aly Tricarico
Maggie (uncredited)
Michele Gambino
Gangster #7 (uncredited)