Are You My First? (2025) | Full Cast

Colton Underwood

Self - Host

Kaitlyn Bristowe

Self - Host

Godwin Asamoah

Self - Contestant

Sara Brito

Self - Contestant

Rachael Staudt

Self - Contestant

Sara Brito

Self - Contestant

Brooklyn Benson

Self - Contestant

Michael Fractor

Self - Contestant

Katya Ferrer

Self - Contestant

Deya Bazan

Self - Contestant

Mike Planeta

Self - Contestant

Madi Kolodgie

Self - Contestant

Andrew Marino

Self - Contestant

Jake Rohrs

Self - Contestant

Hakeem Kiser

Self - Contestant

Carissa Estellee

Self - Contestant

Vivek Sundararaman

Self

Krash Pavic

Self - Contestant

Farha Khalidi

Self - Contestant