The Curious Case of... (2025) | Full Cast

Beth Karas

Self - Legal Analyst

Bam Margera

Self

Steve-O

Self

Kevin Franke

Self

Jessica Bate

Self - Detective, Santa Clara - Ivins PD

Dannii Marie

Self

Nafsika Antypas

Self - Food Entrepreneur

Tony Sharra

Rick Madrid

Isaac J. Conner

Daniel Choate

Lauren Matthias

Self - Podcaster

John Matthias

Self - Forensic Psychcologist

Brian Coogan

Self - Former Rhode Island State Representative

Debbie Lynch

Self - Gates of Praise Leader

Steve Cercone

Self - Retired Detective Seaside PD

Corey Ryter

Nicholas Alahverdian

John Dehlin

Self - Podcaster

Adam Steed

Self - Former Client of Jodi Hildebrant

Connie Gibbs

Self - Former Cult Member

Rick Madrid

Self

Sherrie Calgaro

Self - Mary Day's Half Sister

Simon Pikyavit

Self - Officer, Santa Clara - Ivins PD

Emily Miller

Self - Founder, Colorado Burial Preserve

Mary Lancaster

Self - Former Cult Member

Mary Walker

Self - Marc Walker's Wife

Crystina Page

Self - Victim's Mother

Marc Walker

Self - Sheryl's Ex-Husband

Jeannie Parnell

Self - Mary Day's Half Sister

Joe Bertaina

Self - Retired Detective Seaside PD

Angelika Stedman

Self - Victim's Mother

Heather DeWolf

Self - Victim's Mother

David Leavitt

Self - Former Utah County Prosecutor

Judy Veloz

Self - Retired Police Chief Seaside PD

Blanca Eberhardt

Self - Mortician

Leif DeWolf

Self - Victim's Brother

Paul Steed

Self - Adam's Dad

Faith Hughes

Self - Connie's Daughter

Austin DeWolf

Self - Victim's Brother

Tyler Cunnington

Self - Reporter

Daniel Choate

Self - Former Client of Jodi Hildebrant

Mark Clark

Self - Retired Detective Seaside PD

David Rossi

Self - Nick's Stepfather

Michael Muñiz

Moe Felix

Rona Lotan

Dessa